Showing posts with label Being An Adult. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Being An Adult. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

Why I Started Cooking

I know that some people are born cooks - or at least, born with an affinity for cooking. People like my sister, who by age 20, despite the vagaries and fits of college apartment kitchens, was hosting gourmet dinner parties for groups of ten.

But for me, like for many people I know, the revelation came much later. For most of my 20s (a terrifying phrase, in that I have to now admit that "most of my 20s" are over), the only constant in my life was transience. I went to college 700 miles from home, spent summers and autumns in various apartments and hotels in Italy and New York, and then made the most astonishing leap of all: to New Delhi, where, at last count, I have now managed to occupy six different houses. I've moved more than most people I know, and these moves haven't just crossed physical distances - they've been prompted by necessity and desire, sometimes by catastrophes, often by aspirations.

And despite all this, for many, many years, it never really occurred to me to cook. I rejected cooking as banal and ordinary, a surrender to the domesticity that I had spent so many years of my life trying to abjure.

My first independent kitchen - the first one that counts - was in my college apartment.  I bought pre-packaged hamburgers from the Whole Foods downstairs and ate them with lettuce and tomato but no bun. I learned how to make omelettes by accident, on a trip to New York. I was visiting a friend in Queens, and one evening we found ourselves at home with nothing to eat but eggs. I bravely volunteered to take a turn at the skillet, and was surprised by how delicious the results turned out. It was an experiment, not that I told her that.  And then I made pasta, but this too involved an element of quest. I became convinced, in senior year, that it was possible to make a pasta that fused perfectly the flavors of East and West. I ground cardamom into linguine, dusted noodles in turmeric, sliced ginger over lasagna. It was all perfectly repugnant, and I ended up tossing a lot of it in the trash.

Beneath these attempts there lingered an abstruse reverse competitiveness; the awareness of a fraternal separation of powers between my sister and myself.  She lived in nice apartments, matched her sofas to her drapes, scouted for castoff tables on Craigslist, reinvented her decor with mosaic tiles and embroidery. She owned multiple can openers. As for me, I was too busy for all of that - I was going places.

But where exactly was that? My second independent kitchen was in Neeti Bagh, in a tiny studio apartment above the house of a Bengali doctor and his wife. They treated me like their daughter, although this generosity didn't extend to the table. My counter was a narrow green granite slab, and my range was a single burner with a tiny gas cylinder attached to it by a pipe. I had seven or eight pots and pans, many of them - I'm now embarrassed to admit - gifts from my mother, who packed them in my suitcase when she learned just how ill-equipped I was for any semblance of adult life.

So I started cooking again out of a sense of nostalgia, perhaps. I'd trek to the tiny grocery store in Neeti Bagh, poring over $10 jars of imported olives and pasta sauce. As for cheese, I smuggled it from the US, in enormous Costco bricks that I laid in the bottom of my suitcase like ballast.  In Delhi, surrounded by Indian spices, I still managed an approximation of American food.  Pasta alfredo. Egg salad.  Omelettes. The only difference was the substitution of the occasional Indian cookware. For a while, I managed all my cooking in a single aluminum topiah, hoisting it on and off the burner with a pair of tongs. This arrangement will make sense to Delhi-ites, everyone else will find it literally unimaginable.

And I stuck to the recipes of my hazy past. It didn't occur to me to consult a cookbook, to explore new vegetables or flavors or herbs or whatnot. People would ask me why I didn't learn more Indian dishes; my answer was a thoughtless shrug.  I had come to India expecting that I would learn the dishes my mother made - her spinach rice, her dahi bhalla, her rajma. I don't know how or why I expected that after years of standing senselessly at her elbow, I would magically sprout this talent in her absence.

For a while, I surrendered to Delhi custom and hired a cook. This was no easy task. It's never easy to surrender control of your personal space, and with Shatrugan ("just like the actor, madam") I had more struggles than most. I wanted only Indian food ("but I cook for all foreign peoples") and quantities of oil that he found microscopic. Towards the end, I would wake up in the early morning and perch myself on the living room sofa, watching him out of the corners of my eyes to see exactly how much oil he was adding to our food.  This insane behavior quieted neither of us, and eventually the arrangement ended.

I don't know what I did in Green Park, where I lived for over a year. I did add one dish to my repertoire: after an enlightening dinner at a friend's house, I learned to make Thai curry. (It's not as complex as it sounds.)  I invited friends over for dinner once and made pasta, with a chicken that turned out disturbingly dry.

And then I moved to GK 2, and something changed. I don't know if it was the proverbial page being turned, or the fact that I was tired of eating nothing but pasta and eggs. It might have been this simple: one day, I went down to the vegetable vendor's cart to buy tomato and onions, and I realized - in a blinding flash! - that he had so much more available than that. Suddenly I was looking up recipes for beetroot and sweet kerala, for pumpkin and paneer. I realized - for the first time in 4 years - how much I could do. I realized that it was fun to cook for myself.

Or perhaps it was more complex. Sometime in the past, and without my really thinking about it, my vision of my future life had changed, or perhaps it had merely developed. I met friends at restaurants, at bars, in parks. We ate out, we still do. But I began to imagine a time in my future when I would want to make food for others - when I would want my home to be a refuge in the truest sense.  I remembered how my parents had hosted so many of my high school play rehearsals, and how my mother had cooked for us. I remembered her setting out a banquet at my high school graduation party, while I flitted around in a flowered white dress.

Suddenly cooking didn't seem like a chore, or even a skill, but a part of that complex process by which we create our homes and ourselves. And yet, it was also - like everything - an assertion of the individual self. They say that you cook like your mother did, but I almost never do. If you come to my house, chances are, you will not eat anything that I had growing up. Partly, this has to do with what's available. But mostly, it has to do with the ways I've used cooking as yet another destination on a journey that has taken me further and further into the world - into Thai food, Keralite food, meat (I grew up in a largely vegetarian house).  And perhaps these differences reflect the differences of my mother's life, as well - I grew up eating chicken, fajitas, stir fries. I doubt my grandmother, who has spent the past forty years of her life in roughly the same part of Mumbai, has ever made any of these things.

I don't know at what point a journey becomes a departure, and at what point we can say we have started to come back.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Choosing Optimism

The other day, a friend of mine posted the following question on her FB: "activists and social change-driven people: do you use negative personal experiences and anger and channel these to make change? how?"

In answering her question, I realized something incredibly important: being optimistic is very hard, but it's also very important.

In my life, pessimism manifests in many forms, but the most insidious is the subtle and self-serving belief that people are bad, and that they cannot change.  I first adopted this belief in elementary school, and throughout adolescence I wore it like a shield. If someone disappointed me, they were out of the club.  Fini. Kaput. Etc. I was an island, happy being alone.

Except that I wasn't.  And the older I get, the less I can maintain that illusion to myself or anyone else.

When you believe that people are bad, you certainly save yourself some heartache. You save yourself the incredibly humiliating experience of rejection, of asking for more and being denied. But you miss a great deal more.

The same is true of general optimism.  In the face of a world that is disappointing and unfair, it is easy to say: Forget it. This will never change.  Let me do what I can for myself and forget about everyone else.

But negativity, anger, and hurt are not emotions that change the world for the better.  They are isolating, and in my experience, people who indulge them too much end up lonely, angry and scared.  On the other hand, when I tell myself that people are good - that examples of goodness and courage also exist around me - I find that I want to reach out and improve the world.  Every positively impactful action I've ever taken - whether it's starting a nonprofit or teaching in a slum school - has been an act of faith and an act of optimism.  A belief that things can improve, and that one person's bad decisions - or even a thousand people's bad decisions - are not a global destiny.

Part of this philosophy means surrounding myself with optimistic and positive people - those who open themselves up to change, who take risks, who embrace opportunity, and who treat others with dignity.  People like that are rare, and frankly, possibly a bit demented.  The history of the world is one of extreme injustice and continuing disparity, and fighting that tide is a noble and exhausting endeavor.  But these are also people who have courage, empathy and energy.

Increasingly, I find myself at personal crossroads: moments when I can choose not my destiny, but the way I choose to view the world.  Choosing optimism is scary because it means accepting that your life can be better - but that you have to take responsibility for getting there.  And getting there will probably suck really hard.  It will not be easy.

The same is true of the world.  It is hard to be optimistic about the future because it means that suddenly we bear responsibility for getting there.  But I believe - and I think evidence supports - the contention that people who change the world for the better (and whom we remember) are people who choose optimism, and who choose not to live in fear.

Thursday, April 18, 2013

The Emperor Has No Emoticons

Let me preface this post by saying: every single time I have tried to resolve an inter-personal conflict or issue over email, I have later regretted it.  Let me also preface by saying, This rant is not directed at any particular person.  It's directed at about five very particular people.  Ha.

My long and somewhat tragic history with poorly conceived written correspondence goes back to seventh grade, when a friend and I had a year-long feud through letters.  Imagine, if you will, two teenage girls arguing about everything from the nature of friendship to hair color, in the form of two-page handwritten missives exchanged over the course of months, some of them even mailed to each other during a summer when we were at separate summer camps.  (We put more effort into this fight than many people put into entire marriages.)

The feud ended when I, really enraged, showed one note to another friend.  "Isn't this the most insulting thing you've ever read?" The letter was written in miniscule handwritten letters, in glittery gel pen on black construction paper.  But these artistic choices weren't what offended me. My friend read the letter, handed it back, and said, "Honestly it sounds like she's being really nice and wants things to work."

In my mind, I'd already composed a scathing reply.  I took back the letter and re-read it.  Well-intentioned? Nice? Were we looking at the same text? This was teenage angst, not "To the Lighthouse." How many interpretations were possible?

I didn't write back.  After a brief detente, we resumed being friends and then eventually lost touch.  But in eighth grade something happened that changed the world and ensured that I would never mail such a letter again.

Obviously, I'm talking about the advent of the Internet in our lives.  The Internet has been credited with democratizing everything from banking to literacy to democracy itself.  That's great.  It's also provided us with about 8 million new avenues for passive-aggressive non-communication.

Consider the example of the "amazing friend encounter."  You know what I'm talking about.  This is earth-shattering platonic chemistry. You start talking to someone at a party, not expecting much.  But as the conversation goes on, you realize that you have similar ambitions, you admire each other's wit, you make obscure allusions to Roman history that nobody else understands and/or finds funny.  And you think, we must be friends,  This is fate.  And you part with great intentions, get home, and immediately send a Friend Request, or an email.

"It was really great to meet you last night at Carl's party.  It's rare to meet someone who is as passionate as I am about vintage beer steins.  Let's definitely meet again soon."

No response. And soon enough your early euphoria ebbs, exposing the dry, sandy beaches of humiliation and self-loathing.  Whereas before you were all, "amici aeterni," now you're all, "E tu, Brute?"  And do you really blame them?  It's nearly impossible to tell someone "you're not the one," so how much harder must it be to tell someone, "you're not even one among many"? 

Months later, you run into them again at a party, and scuttle off to your own corner, determined not to make eye contact, consoling yourself with the thought that their new friends are shallow and their clothes are ugly. Or something equally mature.

Of course, this all goes for an even greater toss in the mercurial land of romance.  For example, what to assume when someone doesn't punctuate messages?  Do they simply not care? If a person can't be bothered to insert a semicolon, is he really that into you?  At least you can reassure yourself with the fact that he's not into grammar either. Cold comfort, really.  Thanks to iPhones, we can now have conversations like this:

Friend 1: X doesn't bother to punctuate messages to me.
Friend 2: Let me see. *reads text.  It says something like "r u hr???;!" tries to put a good face on it* Well, it says he was sending from his phone. Excuse the typos, and all that.
Friend 1: But he always used to punctuate his messages.  He had such nice punctuation when we first started dating.
Friend 2: ....

What about when someone doesn't reply to a Facebook message?  What if they replied to a message before?  Were they into you then, and aren't now?  What about the Facebook birthday wish?  Does someone who posts a full "Happy birthday" have better intentions that someone who tosses up the noxious "hbd"?  And what about the no-shows?  They just don't care, right?

E-declarations of devotion, circuitous and tortured as they are, are always, always a bad idea.  Unlike heinous fashion trends such as big hair, shoulder pads or flowered leggings, these e-heart messages were never in style, and thence can never come back in.  I have sent one or two heartfelt messages, each several sentences long, that received one-line replies like, "Don't worry about it! By the way, do you know Mike? He also works in consulting ;)"  What can I say? I'm a glutton for punishment.

And those emoticons!  Is ";)" as cheesy and insincere in emails as a wink would be in person?  Or do we allow for some satiric reserve, the distance implied by the keyboard going from inconvenient to necessary?  Where are the emoticons for the things that really matter? How does one sum up "you rent my heart and destroyed my wellbeing" in a combination of symbols?  ";-noooooooooooo", perhaps?  Or maybe don't bother.

And then of course there's the absurdist "Sorry I just saw this" that arrives weeks, hours or months after a response was called for. This line is almost universally a lie, unless the person you're talking to suffers from some sort of short-term memory loss ala Guy Pearce's character in "Memento." And even then, it's still a lie - the liar just doesn't know it.

Of course, on the Internet we all seem to revert to the same level of maturity we possessed when we first set up an AIM account, using our profiles to exaggerate our age and beauty in the hopes that someone online would fall in love with the real us.  Perhaps in the excess of artifice lies the absence of artifice, but probably  not.  The Internet seems to behave the way a really cheap digital camera does, recasting sentiments that were once grand and sincere as flat and tawdry, leached of all genuine connection to feeling.  "I love you" was once a passionate declaration, along the lines of "I will follow you always" but now, thanks to the Net, we have.  You may love only four or five people in your life, but you can  just about anything.  How convenient.

Of course, I'm not naive enough to believe that the Internet offers us anything other than the opportunity to be more craven than we would be in person, inserting a sort of direct pipeline to the wellspring of cowardice that flows through human nature.  It's not such a bad thing, cowardice, but it's hardly what great civilizations were built on.  Anyone who doubts the ability of the written word to capture - perfect? - real human emotion has never read Emily Dickinson (whose lifestyle, by the way, I'm beginning to envy.)

When it comes to the collaborative sympathetic power of the Internet, the maxim for our online country should be "E Pluribus Asshole."  It turns out that with a million ways to stay in touch, nothing says "I care" like saying "I care"...in person.  But does it have to be?  I can't help but wish, sometimes, for greater sincerity, an acknowledgment that what we type is not mere bullshit to be forgotten but rather the words that sum up who we are.  I suppose most people simply do not care about words as much as I do; it's true that I spend far too much time thinking about what I and other people write.

But then I think about how, generations from now, these may be all the marks we'll leave.  Nobody writes, nobody sends letters.  Will the Internet one day serve as some archive of how we really felt about each other?

----#----

This is my personal blog.  I blog professionally about trends in digital media and entrepreneurship over here.  Read those posts, you might just  them.  Insert ironic smiley.

Saturday, November 3, 2012

Musings on Genius and Maturity

In freshman year of college, a friend of mine told me she was attracted to a guy because she viewed him through "the goggles of excellence."  What she meant was, he was a brilliant musician. She was a spectacular singer and songwriter herself, so I grasped in an instant what she'd find so attractive about unusual talent and dedication.

There's a vast and growing literature out there about excellence, genius and exceptionalism.  Most of it, from what I can tell, is total junk.  But then there's this article in the New York Times, and it redeems the genre (or maybe is the exception that proves the rule.)

After years of interviewing people, it's easy for me to spot people who were labeled as gifted children.  They are articulate, emphatic, professionally fortunate.  Because of this, and because they are used to relating to adults intellectually from an early age, they are often mistaken for being more mature than they actually are.

But this assumed maturity is not the real thing; and Andrew Solomon makes a beautiful study of that point in his article.  He points out that child musical prodigies can often bring a shocking emotional intensity to their performances, but if their fantasies are not replaced eventually with experience, their performances over time grow stale.  Intellect, like everything else, requires fresh air to grow and expand.

On a practical level, extremely gifted children live in their own beautiful but isolated worlds.  I have been shocked, sometimes, at how the most brilliant people I've known have also been emotionally immature, surprisingly so for their age.  I can't help but agree with Solomon that this immaturity can obscure and eventually surpass early intelligence.  At the very least, it can lead to an unhappy and dissatisfied life. (Particularly, it seems, where intimate relationships are concerned.)

Solomon quotes the violinist Yehudi Menuhin, who apparently once said, "Maturity, in music and in life, has to be earned by living."

What's sadder - and what Solomon's article brings out - is that society fails to understand or acknowledge the emotional needs and disadvantages of these children, precisely because they show a mental capacity that can frighten or bewilder even the most ardent well-wisher.  A quick listen to Leonard Bernstein's lectures at Harvard - stunning, bewildering in their scope - demonstrates what I'm talking about.  How many people, after listening to Bernstein's lectures, would feel comfortable addressing him as an equal?  How many people would argue with him, and even if they did, how many would do so in language he would understand or acknowledge?  (I'm picking Bernstein out of a lineup because he displays the superficial traits that I'm talking about.  I have no idea what his emotional state was.)

People who are extraordinary in some ways are still very ordinary in others.  This concept is easier to accept in theory than in practice.

Of course, there's a difference between a prodigy and an extremely brilliant child. (And some people remain lifelong jerks despite ample opportunities to evolve.)  Solomon says in his article that most child prodigies require the assistance of friends and relatives in order to excel.  "A prodigy is a group effort," he says, and I've said before that genius is a collective enterprise.  If that's the case, then perhaps we should reform the expectations of exceptionally talented people, as well as our understanding of them.

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Adventures in Food Preparation

People who read this blog know that occasionally, in between thinking random thoughts about mankind, I go into my kitchen and try to feed myself.  These attempts - I can't call them "efforts" since that implies deliberate and thoughtful labor - almost always end as total routs. Don't believe me?  One time, on a school trip to Italy, I started a grease fire that almost resulted in the evacuation of our hotel as well as the monastery next door.

But that was a nadir - since then, I thought I'd improved. These days, I occasionally even offer my cooking to my roomates, and thus far neither of them has died.

So imagine my horror at today's events.   After a long and truly exhuasting dance class, I came home and decided to make a Thai Green Curry.  I learned this particular recipe from a friend; I watched him do it once and figured it couldn't be that hard a trick to repeat.  I even made a semi-decent Thai Green Curry a few days ago, so I thought I had it down.

How wrong I was.

My first clue that all was not well came within the first two minutes.  This particular Thai Green Curry requires coconut milk, which I buy in cardboard packs from the grocery store.


Today, I'd already started by chopping the vegetables and tossing them into a wok.  Then I cut a tiny hole in the box of coconut milk and started pouring coconut milk into the same wok.

Here's where things got a little strange.  I'm not that familar with coconut milk, arguably, but it has a texture and consistency a little like thinned glue.  But this particular coconut milk was really, really thick.  And it smelled extremely coconut-y.  But I figured, what the hell.

I kept pouring, until I realized that what was coming out of the cardboard box was no longer coconut milk.  What the hell is that?? I thought. Oh, it's a mushroom!  Of course!  I was totally relieved that the thing I was scraping out of the bottom of the coconut milk box was, you know, an inexplicable piece of vegetable that had no real way of even getting into the box instead of, you know, something really, really gross.

Except, obviously, it wasn't a mushroom.

Despite having just held the rancid remains of coconut milk curdle in my hand, I decided to continue cooking, operating on the same principle as a soldier on a battlefield who has yet to realize he's been mortally shot.

The next stage was to boil eggs.  Don't ask me why I thought it was a good idea to put eggs into this dish.  I'll just give you the punchline: I didn't boil them long enough.  So when I popped them off the range and peeled them, I realized that they were extremely, extremely soft to the touch.

So what did I decide to do?

I decided to microwave them.  Now I know that you're never supposed to microwave an egg that still has its shell, but I figured since I'd removed the shells, I was good to go.  I sliced the undercooked eggs in half, slid them into the microwave, and felt pretty good about myself.

Until I heard the explosions, like landmines going off.  I opened the microwave door, only to find the spattered remains of nuked egg spread everywhere.  Steam issued from every vent.  I hadn't just cooked those eggs, I'd obliterated them.

I mopped up the carnage inside the microwave and returned to my curry.  It was bubbling away. The coconut milk gravy was a bit darker than usual, but I was willing to overlook that, even though by that point I was feeling decidedly queasy.

I opened up the little container of cooked rice that I'd meant to use as a base for the curry.  Except it wasn't rice. Somehow, overnight, a normal serving of rice had morphed into an elaborately hard, green and moldy ball.  Kind of looked like a paperweight, only less hygienic.  I stared in dismay at the furry remains.

I leaned over and sniffed the curry.  At this point, my wok could have done double duty as the witches' cauldron in the opening scene of Macbeth.

I combined the curry and the rice, put them both into a neat little plastic takeaway container, and buried the entire sad memory deep, deep in the trash. Then I ate microwave popcorn for lunch.

You know, people rarely believe me when I tell them that I have almost no practical skills, but I'm not being modest.  My cooking is hit or miss.  I don't like to drive, even though it's unpatriotic to admit it. Neither my hunting nor my gathering skills are much up to scratch - the only gun I've ever held was some Indian Army assault rifle, and on an apple picking expedition, I'm usually the one who gets distracted by the view and wanders off.  As a farmer, my most notable skill is being able to forget to water plants that are in front of my face.

Sometimes, I worry about the efficiency of evolution, if we are the selected fittest.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

A few thoughts on "giving back"

My Mom recently told me this story: when she was growing up, her family had a neighbor, a single man in his fifties.  Since India was, in those days, a far less suspicious society, this "uncle" - who worked as an engineer - used to come over every few days and help my mother and her brothers with their homework.

When it came time for him to retire, he moved to the hills and donated all his money to an ashram.  The operators of the ashram took his money and threw him out.  He eventually moved to a small Southern state, earned just enough to establish a small trust, and started a school for girls, where he now goes every day to teach.

As a journalist, I worry about what it means to "give back," since there isn't always a clear relationship between what I do for a living and social benefit (a problem accentuated, recently, by the increasing number of news orgs that are losing their audience to websites).  Another journalist I know recently referred to mass media as "no different from selling soap"; which is depressing even though it's true.

But then I hear stories like the one above, or the story of my own great-grandfather.  He was born in pre-independence India and ran a factory that sold fabric to the British, although after meeting Gandhi he gave part of that up.

But there are a few other interesting facts about him which aren't part of the official biography: as a businessman, he lived in a massive company-provided property.  One year when there was massive flooding in Calcutta, he opened his house to the entire community.  Another year, two schoolteachers at the neighborhood school fell in love, and the parents' association asked him to fire them both.  He talked with the offending couple and ended up sponsoring their wedding.

He sent every one of his three daughters to college (a luxury that he could afford), and when the time came for them to get married, he insisted on marrying them without dowry, thus ending - at least in his family - two of the more regressive and negative traditions in Indian society.

When I look at my grandmother, my mother and myself,  I see clearly the legacy of my great-grandfather's character, of the way he lived his life.  He gave his children an enormous amount of opportunity, and the results are still visible in my family generations later in their values and outlook.

My thoughts distill into two distinct streams: 1) that a profession is, at the end of the day, the sum of what we do "publicly" and while this matters, our "private" decisions (how we treat our families, friends, strangers, etc) often have as lasting an impact and 2) the notion that what we "give back" can be separated from the other aspects of our lives is utterly false.

My great grandfather was not religious, but no one ever heard him raise his voice in anger.  Although he was fluent in five languages, he never looked down on his wife for having no more than an eighth grade education.  His daughters are musicians, artists and poets, his grand-daughters and great-granddaughters have graduate qualifications, careers and independent lives.

By contrast.  When I was 17, I visited my grandmother (on the other side of my family.)  In front of a roomful of people, she asked what I planned to study in college.  I said, "journalism."  Someone else said, "Not medicine?"  She sighed, nodded, and said "well, what do you expect?  She's a girl; after all."  I was speechless, so it fell to my mother to step in and say, "As we all know, girls are smarter than boys - that's why they do better in the classroom."

I'm not sure that my grandmother agreed - but then she, after all, had been pulled out of school at 14 to get married.

Years later, after she'd passed away, I was going through the small stack of documents that counted as her papers.  I found a folded-up piece of newspaper, which when I opened it turned out to be one of the first articles I'd ever had published.  I don't know where or how she got it - she never left the house, and that particular newspaper isn't readily available in the city where she lived.  She had nothing else of her grandchildren's - no college diplomas from my male cousins, none of their academic citations.

For better or for worse, one of my grandmothers lived her entire life believing that women could never equal men.  The other, meanwhile, never doubted it.  In a rapidly developing society like India's, where values, education and prosperity don't clearly align, these are not inconsequential distinctions.  Whatever my great grandfather's factory may or may not have produced, one of the most significant decisions he made in his life was to pass on to his daughters the belief that knowledge has inherent value, and that both men and women benefit from receiving it.

This is what I mean by giving back - it's not just about spouting grand ideas - it's about being an original thinker, about being willing to stand outside the norm when the occasion calls for it.

Here's what I'm beginning to realize: what we "give back" or even "give forward" has nothing to do with stage in life, with financial status, with job description, with extra-curricular activity, with location. It is a function of character, which doesn't depend on circumstances.

Thursday, May 3, 2012

A few thoughts on Facebook and loneliness

To weigh in on this whole "Does Facebook make us lonely" debate: one of the most interesting things about technology is the way it can illuminate gaps or problematic evolution in our national psyche.  By making it easier for us to relate, social media throws light on the ways in which we don't relate.  This is essentially what happened with that lightning-rod Dharun Ravi case, and it's what's happening now with this whole Facebook-and-loneliness conversation.

With Ravi, the most troubling element of his case wasn't the easy availability of potentially invasive technology, it was his lack of knowledge about how to use that technology responsibly, and his even more troubling lack of empathy.  (That our schools and institutions seem to have abandoned the promulgation of empathy - one of the basic building blocks of community and civic virtue - is another troubling insight into the structure of American society, particularly at the so-called "successful" levels.)

With Facebook loneliness, though, the problem seems deeper rooted.  Stephen Marche, author of the Atlantic cover story "Is Facebook making Us Lonely?" says so outright: "Loneliness is at the American core, a by-product of a long-standing national appetite for independence."

Every lifestyle carries a cost.  Loneliness isn't the byproduct of independence, it is the inevitable price (Marche gets to this later on).  The great thing about living an independent life is that it teaches each of us the extent of our individual willingness to pay.

Of modern relationships, Marche writes, "We meet fewer people.  We gather less.  And when we gather, our bonds are less meaningful and less easy."  When my house caught fire and I dramatically left Delhi for Mumbai, I moped bitterly about the lack of support from my network in Delhi.  But when I asked myself how much time, energy and effort I'd invested in most of my relationships, I drew a telling blank.  When I chose to move to Delhi, I decided to leave behind the network of people who had known and nurtured me my entire life.  In a moment of extreme loneliness, I discovered - to a certain extent - that the lifestyle I had in Delhi (carefree, full of parties, unencumbered) carried a price that maybe I wasn't always willing to pay.  But I also saw that my situation was the result of my own choices, and actually had nothing to do with location.   If my relationships were tenuous and poorly defined, it was no one's fault but mine.  How and what to invest in others - and in whom to invest - is a lesson we all must learn, usually painfully.

But it remains unclear in Marche's story - and in my mind - how exactly Facebook is related to the rise in American loneliness.  Increasing loneliness and the increasing availability of technology are concurrent trends - and certainly, the rise of personal technology has helped seal us off in bubbles of our own creation.  I remember an article in Slate a while back that lamented the rise of CD players because they turned public experiences - shared commutes, for example - into private ones, but that suggests that in the absence of consumer electronics we'd spend our commute chatting up and bonding with our fellow passengers.  An unlikely premise, honestly.

In a response in the NY Times, psychologist Sherry Turkle hits on something that seems far more right when she says, "We can't get enough of one another if we can use technology to keep one another at distances we can control: not too close, not too far, just right."

A Facebook identity defeats intimacy because it is watertight.  Relationships work best - and become closest - in those moments when we lose control of the "selves" we've crafted and realize that despite our weaknesses, we can still be loved.  Marche writes, "People who are married are less lonely than single people, one journal article suggests, but only if their spouses are confidantes."

What does it mean to create or cultivate a "confidante"?  How is it possible that people can spend years married to someone - theoretically breathing alongside them part of the day and all of the night - and still not feel like they have a "confidante"?  A friend of mine once referred to the decision to get married as a "leap of faith in conversation" - which brings us back to Turkle's point.  It's not about Facebook, really, but about the nature of what we choose to share with each other.  After I moved back to Delhi, some of the people I knew at that time were surprised to discover that I'd left so dramatically - "we would have helped you," some of them said, repeatedly. 

Some of the most valuable turning points in my personal relationships have grown out of moments of confidence that were - honestly - unintentional, when a personal weight became just too heavy for me to carry alone.  Developing confidantes, I have learned, is a slow and arduous process that involves allowing other people into the very things we hide from our Facebook profiles.  It's about abandoning whatever "brands" we've created for ourselves.  Developing deep relationships is not something that happens to us magically, it is a process far more intense, complicated and personal than sending a friend request.

Here's another interesting correlation: Marche cites an Australian study, "Facebook users have higher levels of total narcissism, exhibitionism, and leadership than Facebook nonusers."

One of those three things is not - or at least shouldn't be - like the others.  If we have abandoned empathy and, in our quest for individuality, lost the ability to talk to, confide in and connect with each other, let's not lay the blame at Facebook's door (login screen?), however convenient that may be.  Let's redefine leadership in such a way that it doesn't correlate with narcissism and exhibitionism.  Let's award power in society to people who display depth of character and intellect, not just a staggering talent for self-promotion.

Marche ends his story, "What Facebook has revealed about human nature - and this is not a minor revelation - is that a connection is not the same thing as a bond."

What Marche's article makes me wonder about American society - and this is not a minor question - is why we need a social network to teach us that.

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

10 Speeches that changed my life

"Always make it personal."  That's the one piece of advice I took away from a college speechwriting course.  Our professor - a kindly man in his 50s who had once written for Reagan - was a big believer in the power of anecdote.  "Most of you will at some point have to give a wedding toast or a graduation party speech," he said. "The worst thing you can do is be generic."

Of course, that's far from the best one can do.  As a former speech club nerd who performed everything from Greek tragedy to Arabic poetry to recitations of the phone book, I've got a personal list of speeches I really like.  YouTube links where possible.

Sheryl Sandberg, Barnard Commencement 2011



Sandberg is the world's universal girl crush prior to this whole Facebook IPO thing that's about to happen.  Her bio is, frankly, frighteningly precocious, but she won my heart ages ago with her outspoken support for female nerdiness.  (Really, not kidding about this.)  Plus, it's heartening to hear an extremely powerful executive cop to feeling like crap because he/she got ripped by an anonymous blog.  Let's be honest - we all hurt when people hate on us, especially when it isn't fair, but no one likes to admit that it hurts, especially at work.  Interestingly, Sandberg's delivery does not sell this speech - she's a bit awkward and she's got laryngitis - but the speech works because it so clearly comes from the heart and so aptly represents her philosophy.

Barack Obama, Democratic National Convention 2004



The speech that won the American presidency.  Unfortunately - or fortunately - not for John Kerry, whom the speech was ostensibly meant to support.  With this speech Obama unwittingly created a movement, proving that even the country that elected George W. Bush twice could still have an electoral soft spot for intellectualism.  In a Newsweek column, Anna Quindlen admitted that when this speech ended, she stood up in the darkness of her apartment and cheered.  That's how I felt, too.  Masterfully orated, beautifully constructed, deeply felt.  It remains the best speech Obama has given to date.

Mary Fisher, Republican National Convention 1992



In Mary Fisher, the AIDS awareness movement found a brave (and socially palatable!) spokesperson.  People might quibble about Fisher's delivery - I think it's a little flat - but there's no denying her sincerity or her artistry.  It's always nice to hear a non-pol speak at one of the conventions, too.  A lot like Martin Luther King Jr and other famous speakers, Fisher transcends what is an intensely personal tragedy. When she says, "I do not want [my children] to think, as I once did, that courage is the absence of fear; I want them to know that courage is the strength to act wisely when most we are afraid," she provides a maxim not just for her experience with AIDS but also for the human experience with darkness.  Sometimes, admitting to fear - or to self-doubt, like Sandberg above - can be the fastest way to win an audience.

African man, Columbia University 2006

"I have lost 50 members of my family to the ethnic cleansing in Darfur."  This remains the most startling statistic I've ever heard.  Many people living in America probably can't name 50 family members without consulting a genealogy.  The circumstances under which I heard this speech were singular.  I was living in Manhattan, and to keep a Muslim friend company I fasted one day for Ramadan and went to iftaar dinner at Columbia University.  The dinner was free, the audience numbered 300.  But the keynote speech, by an African Muslim man who asked how Muslims could stand by while their fellows in Africa were murdered, reduced me.  He quoted the famous line from the Qu'ran (also a line in the Talmud): "'He who saves one life it is as if he has saved all humanity; he who takes one life it is as if he has destroyed all humanity."  There are days when I remember this speech - not just the words, but the effect it had on me - and I feel terribly helpless and terribly guilty. 

Steven Chu, Washington University in St. Louis 2010



After hearing Steven Chu speak at Washington University's graduation (my sister's), I felt cheated that I'd gotten Chicago Mayor Richard Daley, whose speech at my own graduation I honestly could not remember for the life of me.  Graduation speeches are famously lucrative and famously easy, which might explain where there are so many bad ones out there.  Chu's speech is not as powerful as some of the others on this list, but it's a very solid, very respectable commencement address.  Chu's remarks about energy may not have resonated with the entire crowd - for a graduation speech, this one is pretty political - but they serve to illustrate my central point.  It's always better, when tasked with a giving a speech, to speak honestly and personally, and to illustrate grand points with personal examples.

Sojourner Truth, Women's Convention 1851

This is the speech I want to recite every time some jerk takes my taxi, lets the door slam in my face or performs any other act of so-called "feminism."  Great speeches draw on universal themes.  When Truth says, "Nobody ever helps me into carriages, or over mud-puddles, or gives me any best place! And ain't I a woman? Look at me! Look at my arm! I have ploughed and planted, and gathered into barns, and no man could head me! And ain't I a woman? I could work as much and eat as much as a man - when I could get it - and bear the lash as well! And ain't I a woman? I have borne thirteen children, and seen most all sold off to slavery, and when I cried out with my mother's grief, none but Jesus heard me! And ain't I a woman?" I'm reminded of Shylock's famous speech in Merchant of Venice, when he lashes out against anti-Semitism by saying, "If you prick us [Jewish people], do we not bleed?"  Of course, it sets the stage for Shylock's eventual demise, but it's still a great piece of oratory.

William Lyon Phelps, "The Pleasure of Books" 1933

There is just so, so much in this speech that I love that it's hard to pick out a single line, but how about, "There are of course no friends like living, breathing, corporeal men and women; my devotion to reading has never made me a recluse. How could it? Books are of the people, by the people, for the people. Literature is the immortal part of history."  Anyone who feels a deep connection to books - a mental connection so undeniable it sometimes feels bodily - will understand exactly what Phelps, an English professor at Yale, is talking about.  And surely there's something universal about literature or stories; or so many societies wouldn't have felt compelled to ban or burn things they found objectionable.  Phelps' address came less than a month before students at German universities gathered for mass bonfires of literature they considered unpatriotic.

Abraham Lincoln, Gettysburg 1863

Arguably not the best-delivered address in American presidential history.  But it's a great address!  I've generally avoided speeches by sitting presidents because then they would dominate this list, but I make a special exception for Gettysburg, mainly because it's the speech that introduced me to political speeches.  I was 11 or so and visited the Lincoln Memorial for the first time, where this speech is engraved across one wall.  Over the course of subsquent visits to the Lincoln Memorial - and since I grew up near DC, there was always someone visiting who wanted to see the monument - I set myself the job of memorizing the entire thing.  Not all that impressive, since it isn't that long.

William Faulkner, Stockholm 1950


Faulkner's sweet, rolling Southern accent underscores one of the most powerful tributes to the writer's art in recent memory. Rumor has it that he delivered this speech while on a massive bender and the audience barely understood a word of it.  Brave sentiments like, "The poet's voice need not merely be the record of man, it can be one of the props, the pillars to help him endure and prevail," serve as a call to arms, as does "He [the writer] must teach himself that the basest of all things is to be afraid: and, teaching himself that, forget it forever, leaving no room in his workshop for anything but the old verities and truths of the heart."  Despite this self-professed dedication to higher feelings, Faulker himself was, like many articulate and literary men of (only?) his time, a raging drunk and a reckless philanderer.  Can't win them all, I guess.

Unknown woman, unknown time

Bear with me.  I was around six years old when I first heard this speech.  I seem to remember it was at one of the RNCs, but I can't find a record of it now when I look.  The woman spoke about being a rape survivor.  I can still recite pieces of this speech from memory.  The bit about how her husband wasn't home, and the perpetrator of the crime was 17.  The moment at the end when she said, "I remember standing on my porch and trying to count the stars; now I stand at my window, with my door locked, and try to count them."  This speech broke my heart and devastated me.  At the time I couldn't understand how she could talk about something so personal, but I was a kid and didn't really understand much of anything.  Since then I've been to tons of "Take Back the Night" marches, but this is probably the first speech in my life that made an impression on me.

Monday, February 6, 2012

Yet more observations on how to be happy

Here are two interesting passages side by side:

 "I came to poetry relatively late in my life. When I decided to leave my job teaching middle school in order to enroll in an MFA program, I left behind a pension plan, health care, a house, and the small, independent music shop my husband and I had owned for over 20 years. And, frankly, the prospects of finding any sort of financial success or recognition as a poet are not good. Granted, the world seemed like a very different place 15 years ago, but that choice was not, even then, a wise fiscal decision. It was, however, one that changed my life and improved it immeasurably in all of the intangible ways that sustain us essentially. I have been, without question, unusually fortunate, and still, I would describe my present economic circumstances as rather bleak. To have little financial security in middle-age is very different from being broke when one is 25. Most poets live humble lives, I think, and maybe that is by temperament or design, or maybe it is just a necessity. To receive this fellowship is very, very wonderful.  It provides not only economic support in a moment of great need but also no small amount of artistic validation and encouragement. It permits me in some way to honor again my own decision; it reminds me that this is the right life for me to be leading."

"I was so angry with my mother for so long. Now I’m old enough to recognize the disillusion I saw dawning on her face that night. Happiness is elusive. I’ve learned you can become the kind of person you swore you’d never be. Your sense of self can slip out from under you. You can fall so far. She must have known it couldn’t last. Her eyes were closed against the future."

This looks like one of those critical reading exercises from high school, and if this weren't my blog I would actually leave it like that.  (Recently - okay, forever - I've secretly believed that everything worth writing has already been written, and the more I read, the more I feel that way.)  But this isn't a critical reading exercise.

The first passage is Kathleen Graber's artist's statement from when she won an NEA grant, based partly on "The Telephone," which is an amazing poem.  (Seriously, it took Nicholson Baker an entire novel to attempt to say what Kathleen Graber accomplished in just three lines.  Although that part about falling in love with a man's voice over the phone made me shudder with sympathetic and foreshadowed angst, having just advised a younger co-worker to stay away from well-read men precisely because "there is no gold at the end of that rainbow, only coal" but that's just my present opinion)

The second passage is from "The Norwegians," a short story by Elliott Holt.

Recently, I have also been thinking a lot about the relationship between our choices and our happiness, and relatedly, what it means to want something.

I've come to the belief - not really so unique - that we get out of life only and exactly that which we demand.  By which I mean, everyone (either deliberately or not) sets a bar in his or her life, and says to the world "I will accept nothing less than this."  And they get nothing less, but they don't get anything more, either.  (Obviously there are stories of people who randomly win the lottery, but I'm not talking about freak accident.  That happens, but it's not relevant to what I'm discussing)

A very wise friend of mine once told me: "You can't force an opportunity.  But when it arrives, you had better be ready to take it."

The difficult - the most difficult - thing about wanting anything is that the things we really want - success, vindication, love - arrive at their own pace.  It's easy to say you have to wait for what you want, but the reality is that you have to accept nothing less than that.  And maybe people do accept less, and maybe they don't.  Maybe we don't set that bar where we always want to, sometimes we set it where we must.  (Last night at dinner, me and a friend were talking about a mutual friend of ours.  And my friend said of him: "I always got the impression that deep down, all he wanted was to find the girl of his dreams."  Which I thought was a strange observation, because isn't that what everyone wants?  But maybe not, not in the way that I'm talking about wanting things.)

And also somewhat related: I used to tell people that it's not our capabilities that distinguish us from each other, but rather our choices.  But increasingly I also feel like maybe the two aren't very different.  That the most important characteristic a person has is their ability to set that bar.

Here is why I posted those two passages side by side.  In the second passage, the narrator says: "Your sense of self can slip out from under you."  (She's referring to her mother, who in her forties had an affair with a work colleague.)

Meanwhile, in the second paragraph, Kathleen Graber writes "[This grant] permits me in some way to honor again my own decision; it reminds me that this is the right life for me to be leading."

What distinguishes people from each other is their ability to make difficult choices.  To identify happiness, to know exactly where to set that bar in their lives, and then to refuse to compromise on where they have placed it.

But that raises a lot of questions:

If Kathleen Graber hadn't been such a good poet, then she would never have won an NEA grant, and her decision to leave her stable career would be seen as a huge mistake.  She'd be just another failed dreamer (and isn't the world full of those?)  BUT.  Could she have been such a good poet if she didn't want it more than anything?  Is she good because she refused to accept nothing less?  Did she win the NEA grant, and then the PEN prize, and numerous other awards, because she couldn't do anything besides that?  (And could someone who didn't really love poetry, in a way that few of us really ever love what we do, have been able to make those difficult sacrifices for it?)  Or was she just lucky?  (And by the way, there are plenty of people more lucky than her - it's not like she's the Poet Laureate of the United States.  But again, I would compare this second thing with getting struck by lightning or winning the lottery)

In his admittedly unscientific book "Outliers," Malcolm Gladwell says that people who achieve greatness in their field have usually spent about 10,000 hours practicing whatever it is that they want to do.  There are 8,760 hours in a year.

As a kid, I remember my parents forcing me to practice piano, dance, ice skating and whatever else it was that we were studying.  I also remember (and have mentioned before) the example of my old piano teacher, who, when he fractured his arm in multiple places, invented a lever system so he could continue to play the piano with his cast on.  And I remember that apocryphal tale about a famous painter, who, when his hands failed, took to painting with the brush held between his toes.  Anyway.  My point is, we get what we demand out of life.  Nothing less, but usually not more, either.  We get the same thing from ourselves - what we demand.

Sunday, January 22, 2012

On happiness and decision-making

I'm home again!  It's a short and unexpected trip, but I've already managed to remember a few key things:

1.  Stop stressing out.  I'll support this point with a vague anecdote.  Sometimes, you reach a point where you have to make a decision or don't know what you want.  Maybe you're mired in unhappiness because you're trying to force something that isn't natural or just isn't happening at the pace you'd like.   Maybe you've built up an opportunity in your head but it isn't actually the path to what you want.  Being around my family relaxes me and makes me happy.  Even when we fight, it's the easiest thing in the world. It draws me out of whatever weird funk I'm in.  For the past twenty-four hours, I've been wandering around my parents' house, hugging my portable heater, playing the piano and reading the theatre listings in the Washington Post.  It's so nice to be around things that unconsciously make me happy, and to be reminded that it's all going to work out and it's going to be okay.

Sometimes, when struggling with a big decision, the best question to ask is: what easily and unconsciously makes me happy?  Do I feel pressured into something?  Do I feel like what I'm about to do is going to expand my options?

And sometimes, the best thing is to not think about it all.  To do completely unrelated things that make me happy.  And suddenly the right path becomes clear.  For example, I've been really stressed out over a few things in Delhi, and being home has really just reminded me to relax and not worry about it.  I'm going to have a hundred opportunities to be happy, and that's a great position to be in.

One of my best friends recently told me (on Facebook!): "Anika -- I mean this as a friend. You need to relax.  You will be happy.  But if you overthink things, you will kill it."  A really good friend - and the kind of person worth having in your life - is the kind of person who says stuff like that.  Who relaxes you and makes you have fun, even if you initially resist. People who stress you out, who make you behave in a way that takes you further from whom you want to be, or are not easy to be around: are not worth being around.

2.  Focus on happiness, not measureable achievement.  A lot of people feel like they somehow automatically deserve happiness.  This is just not the case.  I was talking with a friend.  She's recently started working as a volunteer in a hospital occupational therapy ward. I've honestly never heard her sound so happy or so confident about herself.  But she only found her passion when she focused on making the people around her happier.  And that in turn led her to what made her happy.

Creating capacity in other people is the number one key to creating it in yourself.  In my current job, I'm responsible for organizing training sessions for our staff and creating institutions that deliver digital stories.  Along the way, I've discovered what I really like doing in life.  But I don't think that would have been possible if I weren't interacting with other people to create meaningful change.  As a result, I've accomplished a lot - and from a measurable perspective, I have done really, really well.  But that came later.  There's no point in trying to do things the other way around.

Or to re-interpret the famous Steve Jobs: find what easily and unconsciously makes you happy.  Everything else will follow.